By Reidun Havnes | The Everyday Sociologist

After publishing two books in English, I received more than five hundred emails from strangers who wanted to help me be seen. I kept every one of them. Together, they tell a story about a market where recognition has become a commodity, and about the people on both sides of it.
An Event That Had Already Happened
The first email that really made me stop came on a Tuesday in July. It was friendly in the sort of way that makes you read something twice. The sender introduced herself as the organiser of a book club in New York, a community of readers who appreciated books that encouraged reflection and personal growth. Her team had selected You Don’t Need Fixing for one of their events, she wrote, and what had moved her most was the reminder that we don’t need to become someone else to be at peace with who we already are. It was almost an exact account of what I had been trying to say in the book.
There was just one thing that didn’t quite fit. The event I had been invited to was scheduled for 20 June, and the email was sent on 7 July.
I replied politely and asked whether there was a new date or if something had gone wrong. The answer came quickly, along with an apology. She had used an old draft. The event was actually on 20 July, and she was pleased I wanted to know more. What followed was a lengthy explanation of why the editorial team had chosen my particular book, how the discussion with readers would work, and what I could expect to gain from taking part. I asked for further details, and in the third email came the $150 reservation fee, followed by a paragraph assuring me that this was not payment for advertising, but a contribution towards planning, moderation and graphics.
I declined. She replied that she was disappointed but respected my decision, and asked whether there was something about the format or the reservation that had made me hesitate. I explained as honestly as I could that, as a new author, I was careful about where I spent my time and money, and that I wanted to build a readership at my own pace. Her final reply was the friendliest of them all. She thanked me for my openness, wished me well and mentioned that she had a colleague who worked as a publicist, should I ever need one.
The book club had a name that suggested erotic literature, while my book is written for young people trying to understand themselves. I found nothing in the correspondence to suggest that anyone had read it. Yet the emails were written in a way that made it feel as though someone had. It was that feeling that made me start collecting them. Over sixteen weeks, the total reached 547 emails, 518 of them from strangers offering to help me be seen.
Dear Web
After a while, I noticed that many of the senders weren’t calling me Reidun. They were calling me Web. «Hi Web», «Dear Web», «Can I Web??» The explanation was fairly ordinary. When I created author profiles on BookBub and Goodreads at the end of June, I used the address web@havnes.no. Apparently, some software had picked it up, treated the part before the @ sign as a first name, and passed it along. Of the emails I collected, 435 went to that address, and around a hundred began with a name I have never had.
Other details pointed in the same direction. One email opened with «Good day, {Havnes}», the curly brackets from the template still in place. Another referred to «[Book Title]». A third offered to recommend a book called The Shadow Within to libraries. I have never written a book by that name. A dozen senders wanted to illustrate my characters, and roughly as many wanted to turn my book into a film or television series, although both my books are non-fiction, about work, emotions and growing up. There is something almost touching about how clearly the machinery reveals itself once you start looking.
In my inbox, I was a row in a spreadsheet. It wasn’t the book that had been discovered. It was the registration.
The timeline pointed in the same direction. Before I created the profiles, I hadn’t received these approaches. The first arrived ten days later, and three weeks after that, 107 arrived in a single week. Since August, there have been around 35 a week, so steadily that it no longer has anything to do with me. I can’t know exactly where the senders found my address, but the timing is hard to ignore. Becoming visible on platforms for readers had, at the very least, made me visible to people selling visibility.
Borrowed Names
Many of the senders seemed to understand that an unfamiliar name might not be enough to make me reply, so they borrowed names that carried weight. Six different editorial identities claiming to represent Chronicle Books in San Francisco appeared in my inbox, all using Gmail addresses. One presented herself as a children’s book editor, wrote eight times from three addresses and praised my «vivid character development». Kensington Publishing appeared as a claimed affiliation, along with several literary agents. I was invited to the Brooklyn Book Festival, the Library of Congress National Book Festival in Washington and the Frankfurt Book Fair, the last invitation coming from someone calling herself Sally Rooney. Other emails were signed Stephen King, James Patterson, Patricia Cornwell and Gillian Flynn, all wondering about my writing process, as one author to another. Radio offers invoked WNYC, NPR station WVXU and Classic FM, with promises of coverage through AP News. The founder of the reading platform The StoryGraph and «Amazon KDP» also appeared among the supposed senders.
All these approaches came from free email accounts, not the official addresses of the organisations they claimed to represent. Several showed clear signs of impersonation. What interested me was not simply that the names were being used, but which names had been chosen.
Pierre Bourdieu described the literary field as a space in which recognition from particular institutions and individuals confers symbolic capital: a publisher choosing you, a festival inviting you, a critic writing about you. Such acts can give a book a different standing from the one it had before. The value lies not only in the attention itself, but in who gives it.
The senders seemed to know this map of prestige. They used the names of publishers, festivals, editors and writers that might make an unknown author pause for a moment. What they offered was not necessarily recognition from those institutions, but an approach that resembled it. The symbolic capital was not theirs to bestow, but they could borrow its outward signs.
Flattery as a Mirror
What struck me most, though, was the tone. As the autumn went on, the emails grew longer and more personal. They mentioned the book title, described its content and told me what made my book important. «You have written something that young people desperately need right now,» wrote one. «What you have crafted is nothing short of extraordinary,» wrote another, in an email that was almost word for word the same as a third from a completely different sender. Eight of them repeated a sentence from my back-cover description, without quotation marks, as though it were their own observation: You don’t need fixing. You need space to understand yourself.
It is flattery, and easy enough to dismiss. Yet it touches something worth examining. Axel Honneth describes recognition as a fundamental human need, something that matters to how we develop our relationship with ourselves. For a new author, this becomes very concrete. You have spent years on something that is now out in the world, and what you are waiting for, more than anything, is a sign that someone has read it. The market in my inbox seemed to understand this. What I was being offered was never readers, but the feeling of having been read.
The irony was hard to miss. My book is about young people under pressure to become better versions of themselves, and about the need to be understood rather than fixed. The flattery used the book’s own message as bait, appealing to the very need the book describes.
There is a difference between being approached as a person and being approached as a potential customer. The outward signs of attention were all there in the emails: my name, the book title, its message, even phrases that sounded like personal responses to reading it. But the attention had a direction. It was meant to lead to a reply, an agreement or a payment. What looked like an encounter between a reader and an author was often a sales process that had not yet introduced itself as one.
There was also an opposite strategy, and it was just as revealing. During the large wave in July, more than a hundred offers of reviews arrived, many sent to undisclosed recipient lists. Several ended with a moral warning. «Review beggars» and «cheapskates» could delete the email, as could «entitled authors who think the world owes them freebies». One sender simply wrote «pathetic losers».
Where one strategy flatters, the other shames. Yet both play on the idea of what kind of author you want to be. Erving Goffman was interested in how people try to save face in social encounters, and how other people’s responses can affirm or threaten the image we wish to present of ourselves. One email offers you a better face. The other suggests what kind of person you must be if you don’t reply.
Selected
One word kept returning: «selected». I had been chosen, handpicked, one of a very few. And there was urgency, because the offer was valid for only 48 hours, this was the «final call», and in September I was offered a discount because we had entered the «Ember months». More than seventy emails had subject lines beginning with «Re:», as though we were already in a conversation, although I had hardly replied to any of them.
When the price finally appeared, it was often small. Five to twenty-five dollars for a TikTok video, thirty for a place in a catalogue, forty for a drawing of a character who doesn’t exist, around a hundred and twenty to have a radio interview «syndicated» to news agencies, and a hundred and fifty for a place in a book club. Each individual amount could seem manageable. It is easier to say yes to a small experiment than to a major investment, especially when you are told the opportunity is about to disappear.
One category surprised me more than the others. Sixty-three of the emails contained no offer at all. «Am I reaching out to an author?», «Hey, how are you?», «Are your books on Goodreads?» One way of understanding them is as attempts to establish whether the address is active and whether there is a person at the other end. A reply gives the sender something the original mailing list cannot: confirmation that someone is actually reading and responding.
In his 1952 essay On Cooling the Mark Out, Erving Goffman examined what happens when people have to come to terms with the collapse of an expectation or an idea of themselves. His starting point was the confidence game, but his argument went further. People often need help dealing with the loss of a role, a position or an image of who they are.
I thought about this when I reread the book club correspondence. After I had declined, the friendly tone did not disappear. The sender showed understanding for my decision, praised my openness and offered to put me in touch with a publicist. It may have been another attempt to sell me something. It may also have been a way to end the conversation without either of us losing face. I don’t know what she was thinking. But I was struck by how much effort had gone into preserving the feeling of a pleasant encounter, even after I had turned down the offer.
The Other Side of the Email
It would have been easy to end the story here, with the author who saw through it all. But there is another side to the material, one that only comes into view when you try to read the emails from the sender’s side of the screen.
One came from a girl who said she was seventeen and made book trailers and graphics for authors. She wrote that her father was absent, that her mother was carrying the responsibility for the family alone, and that every assignment meant a great deal to her. Four days later, she wrote again. She understood that I might not be interested, but asked me to reply anyway, because simply knowing that someone had seen her message would give her the courage to keep going.
I don’t know whether her story is true. It may be another tactic, like the others. But it made me think about the people sending these emails.
Many of the emails contain traces of different linguistic backgrounds. Expressions such as «Happy new month», «Ember months», «I was opportuned to» and «kindly» occur in varieties of English used in parts of West Africa, while the rest of the message often follows a polished American marketing template. Some offer services through the freelance platform Fiverr. Sender names change, but the templates recur, and the same offer arrives from several different addresses.
It is tempting to form a picture of who these people are. Young freelancers, perhaps, trying to earn a living in an international market. But language does not tell me where the sender is sitting, and a Gmail address tells me little about the person behind it. The material shows how the offers are constructed, not who all the people behind them are.
Still, somewhere, there are people sending these emails. Some have written the texts; others may simply have been given a template to use. Some work alone; others may be part of larger networks. I don’t know. All I can see is the result of their work, and how much effort has gone into getting a stranger to reply.
The language also tells us something about who the senders are trying to resemble. Words such as «visibility», «discoverability», «curated» and «selected» recur throughout. They are the same words used in ordinary book marketing, including the newsletters I receive from established services such as BookBub. There, too, the stories are about authors finding their readers, increasing sales and perhaps one day being able to make a living from writing.
The questionable offers, then, are not speaking a foreign language. They use a language that already exists in the market, borrowing both the expectations and the dreams that come with it. The difference lies in what is actually being offered, who is behind it and whether the promises can be substantiated. But in an inbox, the two kinds of approaches can look remarkably alike.
That does not make misleading marketing any less problematic. Someone who pays for something that is never delivered can lose both money and trust. But it changes what I become curious about. Not only who is trying to sell what, but how a market has emerged in which attention can be offered, packaged and priced in so many different ways.
On one side of the email sits an author who has spent years on a book and is waiting for a sign from a reader. On the other may be someone who has spent the day sending offers and is waiting for a reply. I know little about the people behind the addresses, but I know that both situations are possible. And I find myself thinking that the same email can contain two quite different hopes of being seen.
Is Anyone There
I have barely replied to any of them since July, but I intend to keep collecting them. Not because each individual email is particularly interesting, but because together they say something about the time we live in. About how visibility has become a commodity, how recognition can be imitated, and how it is possible to create the impression of a personal encounter without any real encounter taking place.
The recognition I hope for as an author does not necessarily come with grand words. It may come from a reader who tells me what a particular sentence made her think about. Or from someone who never gets in touch, but carries something from the book into their own life. It cannot be ordered with a reservation fee, and it does not need to prove that it has read me by quoting the back cover back to me.
One of the questions that kept appearing was also the shortest. It came without an offer and without flattery, often with one space too many before the question mark, as though someone had typed it quickly and sent it on to a hundred others.
I read it differently now than I did in July.
Am I reaching out to an author?
Theoretical References
- Bourdieu, Pierre (1993). The Field of Cultural Production. Columbia University Press.
- Goffman, Erving (1952). «On Cooling the Mark Out: Some Aspects of Adaptation to Failure». Psychiatry, 15(4), 451–463.
- Goffman, Erving (1955). «On Face-work: An Analysis of Ritual Elements in Social Interaction». Psychiatry, 18(3), 213–231.
- Honneth, Axel (1995). The Struggle for Recognition: The Moral Grammar of Social Conflicts (trans. J. Anderson). Polity Press.